For fishing in calm water, both sit-on-top kayaks and sit-in kayaks have their pros and cons, but sit-on-top kayaks are generally considered better for fishing in most cases. Here’s why:
WHY SIT-ON-TOP KAYAKS ARE OFTEN BETTER FOR FISHING:
- More Space & Accessibility: Open deck design makes it easy to store and access gear, tackle boxes, rods, etc.
- Easier to Move Around: You can shift position, swing your legs over the side, or even stand up in wider models for casting.
- Self-Bailing: Scupper holes allow water to drain out, so you’re not sitting in a puddle if you get splashed.
- More Stability: They’re typically wider, which adds to balance—especially useful when you’re reeling in a fish.
- Easier to Get On/Off: Great if you’re hopping in and out a lot, or in shallow water.
WHEN SIT-IN KAYAKS MIGHT BE BETTER:
- Colder Weather: You’ll stay drier and warmer because you’re enclosed.
- More Efficient Paddling: Often tracks straighter and can be easier to paddle over longer distances.
- Lower Profile: Less affected by wind due to lower seating position.
ADVICE FOR CALM WATER FISHING:
Go with a sit-on-top kayak for comfort, storage, and ease of fishing unless you’re dealing with colder climates where staying dry is key.
